Volume I, No. XLIII
The pizza box case loses its name and gains a theory: Russian subsidies to Turkish boxmakers
The ITC has found a reasonable indication that corrugated die-cut boxes from China, Malaysia and Türkiye injure U.S. producers. The case, renamed from 'pizza boxes' at initiation, now tests Commerce's 2024 rule on transnational subsidies.
The petitions arrived at the International Trade Commission on September 9 under the title “Corrugated Pizza Boxes.” By October the Commission had renamed its investigations “Corrugated Die-Cut Cardboard Boxes,” to match the name Commerce had adopted4. The change is more than clerical. On November 17 the Commission published its finding that there is a reasonable indication that a U.S. industry is materially injured by imports of these boxes from China, Malaysia and Türkiye, sending the case into its final phase1. What began as a petition about a single food-service item has become a case defined by flute heights, die-cut blanks and third-country processing. It has also become one of the early tests of the Commerce Department’s willingness to countervail subsidies that one government pays to producers in another.
The instrument: Title VII and a low first bar
The case runs under Title VII of the Tariff Act of 1930, the antidumping and countervailing duty laws. The petitioners are the American Pizza Boxes Manufacturers Coalition, whose members are Smurfit Westrock plc and Pratt Industries, Inc., together with the United Steelworkers1,2. They filed dumping petitions against all three countries and a subsidy petition against Türkiye alone2,3.
The Commission’s preliminary vote applies the lowest standard in the process. Section 733(a) of the Act, 19 U.S.C. 1673b(a), asks only whether, “based on the information available to it at the time,” there is “a reasonable indication” of injury or threat6. The Commission made that finding under sections 703(a) and 733(a), with Commissioner Samuel T. Negatu not participating, and completed its determinations on November 131. Its written views appear in USITC Publication 58101.
Commerce, for its part, took extra time to open the case. It extended its initiation deadline by 20 days to examine industry support, then found that the petitioners accounted for more than 50 percent of domestic production, which spared it from polling the industry2. Because domestic production figures were not available, the petitioners used their own 2025 shipments as a proxy, and Commerce accepted the substitute2. Both the dumping and the subsidy investigations were initiated on October 192,3.
The statute then sets the clock. Commerce must reach a preliminary dumping determination within 140 days of initiation unless the deadline is postponed, and the subsidy determination is due within 65 days on the same condition3,6. An affirmative preliminary determination is the point at which Commerce orders a cash deposit, bond or other security on each entry6.
The mechanism: from pizza box to die-cut blank
The scope Commerce published describes “a type of box or carton for use in the food service industry, including to hold pizza pies”2. The operative terms are physical. Covered boxes are made of corrugated paperboard with a nominal flute height between 1.1 and 4.4 millimeters, the B, C, D and E flutes or equivalents2. A finished, assembled box must be at least five inches in length and width, no more than 40 inches in either, and no more than four inches high2. The scope reaches flat die-cut blanks “whether finished or unfinished and assembled or unassembled,” printed or blank, coated or lined, and measured by the die-cut shape even when blanks are imported joined by nicks or perforations2. Boxes “generally” lack locking tabs, interlocking side panels and similar closures2.
Two provisions do most of the work for compliance teams. First, the 40-inch ceiling is new. As Clark Hill summarized the petition as filed, the original language set no maximum length or width; the same summary said pizza boxes made up about 95 percent of the merchandise the petition described13. Second, the scope covers boxes that undergo printing, trimming, folding or further die-cutting in a third country2. Clark Hill read the petition to treat the country where the corrugated sheet is made as the country of origin13. A Chinese blank printed in Vietnam remains a Chinese blank.
Classification will not settle much. The boxes typically enter under HTSUS 4819.10.0020, which Commerce calls “a basket category under which non-subject merchandise may also enter”2. For that reason Commerce said it could not rely on Customs entry data to choose respondents and would instead send quantity-and-value questionnaires to the largest producers it could identify2. The petition named 15 producers or exporters in Malaysia and 76 in Türkiye2.
The numbers moved between petition and initiation. The petitioners alleged dumping margins of 96.62 to 568.50 percent for China, 110.73 percent for Malaysia and 120.65 to 210.37 percent for Türkiye9. Commerce’s recalculated estimates at initiation were lower at the top: 97.71 to 297.26 percent for China depending on the surrogate country (Brazil, Mexico or Türkiye), 83.72 to 116.58 percent for Malaysia, and 51.27 to 92.81 percent for Türkiye2. Because China is treated as a non-market economy, its normal value rests on surrogate values, and for Malaysia and Türkiye the petitioners built constructed values from a U.S. producer’s input rates2. These are initiation estimates, not rates anyone will pay.
The effect: who pays, and the case for relief
The petitioners’ account of injury is straightforward. They say subject imports rose 130 percent from 2023 to 2025 and kept rising in 20269. In the initiation notice, Commerce lists their claimed harms, among them lost market share, underselling, facility closures and declines in production and employment, and finds the allegations adequately supported for initiation2. According to Pratt, as reported by Packaging Dive, about 3 billion pizza boxes are made in the United States each year11. Fastmarkets, drawing on its capacity data, ranks Smurfit Westrock as the second-largest U.S. integrated containerboard and corrugated box company and Pratt as the fifth, and described them as the two largest U.S. producers of pizza boxes12.
The cost falls first on importers of record, who would post deposits on entries once Commerce’s preliminary determinations are affirmative6,10. Clark Hill, writing for purchasers, warned that deposits could affect “pricing, sourcing decisions, contracts, and product availability,” and named distributors, restaurant suppliers, pizza chains and food service companies as the affected buyers13. It also told importers to watch for a critical circumstances finding, which “in some cases may result in retroactive duty liability”13. The firm did not estimate a price effect, and none appears in the record this piece draws on.
The case has an organized opposition. At the Commission’s September 30 conference, White & Case appeared against the duties for Modern Oluklu Mukavva Ambalaj, a Turkish producer, and Eren Packaging US Inc., with Modern Ambalaj’s export manager as witness; Lanca Sales, Inc. appeared as an interested party5. Their arguments are contained in the Commission’s record rather than in any public summary this piece draws on.
The longer view: Russian subsidies and a box the old order missed
The novel element sits in the Türkiye subsidy case. The petitioners allege that Russian government subsidies benefit Turkish producers9. Commerce wrote to Moscow about “Alleged Transnational Subsidy Programs” on September 10, met Russian officials on September 23 and received a Russian letter the next day; it consulted the Turkish government on September 253. It initiated on 66 alleged programs in all, over a period of investigation covering calendar 20253.
Commerce could not have done this before April 24, 2024. Its rule of that date dropped the regulatory bar on such claims, stating that Commerce “will investigate and countervail transnational subsidies” and that section 701 of the Act “does not impose geographic limitations”7. The Journal examined the same rule in the Mexican railway tank car case, where the alleged benefactor was China. In the box case the alleged benefactor is Russia, and the benefit would have to be traced to Turkish box plants.
Paper packaging has been here before, though only in part. Commerce has kept a dumping order on folding gift boxes from China since January 2002, continued most recently in November 2023 after a fourth sunset review8. That order excludes boxes made of corrugated paperboard8. The new case reaches the material the old one left out.
What comes next is set by Commerce. Petitioners’ counsel expects the Türkiye subsidy determination in February 2027 and the dumping determinations in April 2027, both assuming postponements10. Rebuttal comments on scope and product characteristics are due November 192. Whether Commerce finds a countervailable Russian program, and how it would measure the benefit to a Turkish box plant, remains open.