Skip to the text

National Statecraft Journal

Volume I, No. XLIV

The plywood orders arrive ten weeks late and one product narrower than the case Commerce investigated

Commerce has issued antidumping and countervailing duty orders on hardwood and decorative plywood from China, Indonesia and Vietnam. The Commission's split like-product finding removed softwood structural plywood, and the timing leaves entry windows with no duty at all.

Section 736(a) of the Tariff Act of 1930 gives the Department of Commerce seven days. Once the U.S. International Trade Commission notifies it of an affirmative injury determination, Commerce “shall publish an antidumping duty order” within that week4. The Commission notified Commerce on September 4 that dumped and subsidized hardwood and decorative plywood from China, Indonesia and Vietnam injures a U.S. industry1. The orders appeared in the Federal Register on November 17, by this journal’s count 74 days later, signed November 121,2. The delay matters less than what filled it. The Commission divided the merchandise Commerce had investigated into three domestic like products, and Commerce took two rounds of comment to rebuild the scope around that division1. The orders that resulted are narrower than the investigation, and for some entries they come with no duty at all.

The instrument: one investigation, three like products

Title VII of the Tariff Act divides the work. Commerce decides whether merchandise is dumped or subsidized; the Commission decides whether imports of the “domestic like product” injure an American industry, and it draws the like-product lines itself. Here it drew three: hardwood and decorative plywood; stamped and certified softwood structural plywood; and softwood structural plywood “downfall,” panels meant to be certified that failed for manufacturing defects1. It found material injury on the first and terminated the investigations on the other two “on the grounds of negligibility”3. Two commissioners, Bartholomew Thanhauser and David Foley Jr., did not take part3.

Negligibility is a volume test. Under section 771(24), imports from a country are negligible if they account for less than 3 percent of all imports of the like product in the 12 months before the petition, unless the countries investigated on the same day together exceed 7 percent5. For countervailing duty cases involving developing countries the thresholds rise to 4 and 9 percent5. The test is applied to imports of each like product, so the way the Commission draws the lines decides which volumes are compared with which. The public notices do not give the shares for the two softwood products; those are in the Commission’s report.

When either agency’s final answer is negative, section 735(c)(2) requires Commerce to end suspension of liquidation and refund cash deposits7. That is what now happens to the two softwood products.

The mechanism: what is covered, and which entries escape

The final scope covers “hardwood and decorative plywood, and certain veneered panels,” defined as a flat panel of two or more veneer plies with a face or back veneer of hardwood, softwood or bamboo1. Coatings, overlays and minor processing do not take a panel out, and processing in a third country does not change its origin1. The excluded list is long: structural plywood stamped to U.S. Products Standard PS 1-22 or PS 2-18, panels already under the January 2018 China hardwood plywood orders, multilayered wood flooring, assembled and ready-to-assemble furniture and kitchen cabinets, finished table tops and countertops, and certain laminated veneer lumber door components1.

Two scope changes follow the Commission’s split. First, a structural panel qualifies for exclusion only if it bears the certifying agency’s stamp identifying the agency, the standard or grade, and the mill number1. Second, downfall panels are now excluded expressly: panels from a facility certified to PS 1-22 or PS 2-18, produced in a run intended to meet the standard, that missed the stamp because they failed bond, veneer-grade or other criteria1. Parties argued over whether importers should certify these claims at entry. Commerce did not decide; it said it intends to address certification “in a changed circumstances review under section 751(b)” at a later date1.

The deposit rates are those of the July final determinations. China carries a 185.96 percent antidumping deposit and an 88.96 percent subsidy rate for every exporter1,2. Indonesian dumping deposits run from 15.39 percent for PT Wijaya Cahaya Timber to 84.94 percent, on adverse facts available, for PT. Mustika Buana Sejahtera, with 18.06 percent for all others; Indonesian subsidy rates run from 4.22 to 128.66 percent, with 40.87 percent for all others1,2. Vietnam has an 84.95 percent dumping deposit and a 47.68 percent subsidy rate, except 165.39 percent for Junma Phu Tho1,2. Petitioners’ counsel puts the Chinese combination at 275 percent9.

The timing produces three kinds of entry that will not pay what the rates suggest.

  • The provisional gap. Section 733(d) limits provisional measures to four months, or six at exporters’ request [6]. Antidumping measures, extended to six months, took effect March 2, and August 28, 2026 was their last day; Indonesian and Vietnamese entries from after August 28 to the day before the Commission’s September 9 notice will be liquidated without antidumping duties [1]. Subsidy measures ran four months, from January 22 to May 21; entries from all three countries after May 21 and before September 9 owe no countervailing duty [2].
  • The softwood refunds. Stamped structural plywood not previously excluded, and downfall panels, entered since March 2 (antidumping) or January 22 (subsidies) get their deposits back [1, 2].
  • The critical circumstances refunds. Commerce had reached back 90 days before its preliminary findings for China, and on subsidies for Vietnam. The Commission found that those imports were not likely to undermine the orders [3]. Commerce has instructed CBP to refund deposits on Chinese entries from December 2, 2025 to March 1, 2026 for dumping, and on Chinese and Vietnamese entries from October 24, 2025 to January 21, 2026 for subsidies [1, 2].

Interested parties who want notice of future scope and circumvention requests have 30 days from November 17 to enter an appearance on each order’s annual inquiry service list1.

The effect: panel makers, RV builders and the lauan question

The petitioner is the Coalition for Fair Trade in Hardwood Plywood: Columbia Forest Products, Commonwealth Plywood, Manthei Wood Products, States Industries and Timber Products3. Its counsel called the August 19 vote “a landmark win for American hardwood and decorative plywood producers,” and said the vote was unanimous9. On the softwood termination, the firm’s reading was that “the petitions focused on decorative plywood, all of which was included in the ITC’s affirmative determination”9. The National Hardwood Lumber Association, which backed the ruling, urged “a comprehensive, all-of-government response” beyond the case itself10.

The most visible objection on the buyers’ side came from recreational vehicle builders. The RV Industry Association told the Commission at its July 16 hearing that ultra-thin tropical plywood from Indonesia, known in the trade as lauan, does not compete with U.S. hardwood plywood, and described it as a critical input for RV sidewalls and roofs with no domestic substitute of the same performance11. The Commission’s affirmative finding includes Indonesian lauan, by the association’s account, and it said it would review the decision with members11. For an Indonesian exporter at the all-others rates, deposits come to 58.93 percent of entered value by this journal’s addition1,2. Whether lauan buyers shift to Indonesian producers with lower company rates, or to origins outside the orders, is a question the public record does not yet answer.

The longer view: the third plywood fence, and its gate

The Journal examined Commerce’s final determinations in July, when the case was framed as the third attempt to fence one product. Plywood covered by the January 2018 China hardwood plywood orders is outside this scope1. In July 2023 Commerce found that panels completed in Vietnam from Chinese veneers and core platforms were circumventing those orders8. The new orders were written to reach the trade that moved around them, including third-country processing1.

What the Commission added is a gate in the fence. Structural plywood stays outside, and the line between in-scope decorative plywood and excluded structural panels is a stamp and a mill number1. That design puts heavy weight on certification, which is why the importers’ group and the petitioner fought over whether to require importer certifications, and why Commerce has deferred the question to a changed circumstances review with no date set1. The next dated steps are administrative: the service-list deadline in mid-December, then November 2027, the orders’ first anniversary month, when Commerce publishes the opportunity notice for them1. Petitioners’ counsel notes that the rates may be reviewed annually from then on9.