Skip to the text

National Statecraft Journal

Volume I, No. XXXVIII

Nine years on, NAFTA's last softwood lumber panels close the 2017 investigations

Binational panels created under NAFTA, a treaty since replaced by the USMCA, have affirmed Commerce's remands in both original Canadian lumber cases. The subsidy rate for exporters without a later review falls from 14.19 to 12.80 percent, and a recalculated dumping margin is still to be published.

For nine years, 14.19 percent was the subsidy rate Commerce set in its 2017 investigation for Canadian softwood lumber exporters it had not examined individually. Since October 29, 2026 that rate has been 12.80 percent1. The change did not come from a new investigation or a negotiated settlement. It came from a NAFTA binational panel, a body created under a treaty the three countries have since replaced with the USMCA, which on October 5 affirmed Commerce’s second redetermination and dismissed Canada’s challenge to the 2017 subsidy finding4. A second NAFTA panel affirmed Commerce’s second remand in the companion dumping case on November 6, and notice of that decision appeared in the Federal Register today2. Between them the two decisions close the litigation over the original determinations in the fifth softwood lumber dispute, and they show what Chapter 19 review delivers in practice: real changes to the rates, made so late that most importers no longer pay them.

The instrument: a court that is not a court

Chapter 19 of NAFTA let a party replace domestic judicial review of an antidumping or countervailing duty determination with review by a panel of five, drawn from both countries, applying the importing country’s own law. U.S. statute gives the arrangement teeth. Under section 516A(g) of the Tariff Act of 1930, once panel review is requested under Article 1904 of NAFTA or Article 10.12 of the USMCA, the determination “is not reviewable” in the Court of International Trade, and no U.S. court may review it7. When a panel remands, Commerce must, within the period the panel sets, “take action not inconsistent with the decision of the panel,” and that action is itself shielded from judicial review7.

Commerce describes the panels as stepping “into the shoes of the courts they are replacing,” and applies to them the same notice rules that the Federal Circuit set in Timken for trade court judgments1. A decision that is “not in harmony” with the original determination must be published, after which Commerce amends the determination1,7. The standard of review is the trade court’s: the subsidy panel quoted the rule that Commerce’s remand results stand if they follow the remand order, rest on substantial evidence and are otherwise lawful, and that a panel may not substitute its judgment where the record supports two views4.

The USMCA kept the mechanism as Article 10.12, which is why the statute names both agreements7. The 2017 cases were filed under NAFTA and finished there3,8.

The mechanism: what each panel decided

The subsidy panel, file USA-CDA-2017-1904-02, chaired by Robert E. Ruggeri, issued its first decision in May 2024 and remanded parts of the 2017 determination1,8. Canada’s then trade minister, Mary Ng, welcomed that ruling as a finding that the U.S. duties were inconsistent with U.S. law, while saying Canada was disappointed with parts of it10. Commerce filed its first remand on December 17, 2024; the panel remanded again on March 6, 2026, and Commerce filed its second remand on June 17, 20261.

Two issues remained at the end. On Alberta stumpage, the panel had asked why Commerce refused to adjust the conversion factor used with its Nova Scotia private-timber benchmark. It found substantial evidence on both sides and held that Alberta had not shown its adjustment was “the only reasonable outcome on this administrative record”4. On log export restraints, Commerce’s second remand concluded that the restraints imposed by Canada and British Columbia do not provide a financial contribution, and it recalculated the rates without them; the panel affirmed4. Its conclusion reads, in full: “The Panel having affirmed all issues before it, this action is hereby dismissed”4.

The NAFTA Secretariat issued its Notice of Final Panel Action on October 19, and Commerce amended the 2017 determination as follows1:

  • Canfor and its cross-owned affiliates, from 13.24 to 12.49 percent
  • J.D. Irving, from 3.34 to 2.96 percent
  • Resolute FP Canada, from 14.70 to 13.90 percent
  • Tolko, from 14.85 to 11.01 percent
  • West Fraser, from 17.99 to 16.73 percent
  • All others, from 14.19 to 12.80 percent

The dumping panel, file USA-CDA-2017-1904-03, took a different path. Its October 5, 2023 decision remanded three issues: the deduction of export taxes collected under the 2006 Softwood Lumber Agreement, the use of log inputs to judge when Resolute’s Atikokan mill reached commercial production, and Commerce’s differential pricing analysis using the Cohen’s d test5. Commerce filed its remand on April 30, 2024 and recalculated the margins. The panel then stayed the case from July 2024, at the Canadian parties’ request, to await the Federal Circuit’s ruling in Stupp5.

That ruling and Marmen, decided in April 2025, changed the outcome. In Marmen the Federal Circuit held it unreasonable to use Cohen’s d where the data are not normally distributed, equally variable and sufficiently numerous5. The domestic petitioners’ coalition argued that those cases bore on whether a pattern of significant price differences existed, not on whether Commerce could account for one5. The panel, chaired by Daniel B. Pickard, affirmed Commerce on the export taxes and on Resolute’s start-up costs, but on February 19, 2026 it remanded “the re-calculation of the dumping margin,” noting that Commerce itself accepted the remand should bar use of the Cohen’s d test5. Commerce’s second remand followed; the panel affirmed it on November 62,8. The recalculated margins will take effect when Commerce publishes an amended determination, as it did in the subsidy case1. The 2018 order set them at 7.28 percent for Canfor, 3.20 percent for Resolute, 7.22 percent for Tolko, 5.57 percent for West Fraser and 6.04 percent for all others, measured over October 2015 through September 20165,6.

The effect: who sees the new rates?

Fewer importers than the headline numbers suggest. Commerce said the amended subsidy rates do not change current cash deposits for Canfor, J.D. Irving, Resolute, Tolko and West Fraser, because each has a superseding rate from a later administrative review1. GHY International, a customs broker, read the notice the same way11. Revised deposit instructions go to Customs only for companies with no superseding rate, which pay the all-others rate of the investigation1.

That group is real, if narrow. This journal’s earlier coverage of the 2024 review noted that a Canadian exporter never covered by a review still pays the original investigation rates: 6.04 percent for dumping and 14.19 percent for subsidies. For such an exporter the subsidy deposit is now 12.80 percent1. The dumping half of that exporter’s deposit will move again once Commerce publishes the amended dumping determination2,6.

For Canada and the provincial governments, the value of the outcome lies partly in the reasoning. A finding that British Columbia’s log export restraints are not a financial contribution, affirmed by a binational panel, now stands as a reviewed holding on the 2017 record4. For the U.S. industry, the panel upheld Commerce on Alberta stumpage, on the 2006 export taxes and on Resolute’s start-up adjustment, and both orders remain in place4,5.

The longer view: slow review and a narrowing docket

The original determinations were published on November 8, 20171,6. Final panel action in the subsidy case came almost nine years later, and in the dumping case the second remand was affirmed on November 6, 2026, two days short of the ninth anniversary1,2. Most of the time went to remands and to waiting on parallel U.S. litigation1,5.

Canada has already narrowed the field. British Columbia’s government records that Canada moved in September 2025 to withdraw all claims in its USMCA challenges to the first and second administrative reviews of the dumping order, and the panels granted voluntary dismissal8. The USMCA panel on the first subsidy review, covering 2017 and 2018, affirmed in part and remanded in part on October 8, 2026, so a determination from that period is still open8,13.

Two dated steps follow. Commerce must publish a Notice of Final Panel Action and an amended dumping determination for the November 6 decision, following the Timken practice it applied to the subsidy case1. For court decisions, the statute requires such a notice within ten days7. Separately, Commerce is taking comments until November 30, 2026, in docket ITA-2026-0100, for its semiannual Softwood Lumber Act report to Congress on subsidies from Brazil, Canada, Germany and Sweden12. Global Affairs Canada describes the November 6 decision as effectively concluding Canada’s challenge to the dumping determination9. What the recalculated dumping margins turn out to be is the one number the record does not yet show.