Volume I, No. XLVI
Canada takes the 2024 softwood lumber review to USMCA panels, the seventh straight review to be challenged
On November 18 Canadian governments and sawmills asked for Chapter 10 panel review of both 2024 lumber review results, the same day a corrected subsidy rate took effect. The earliest comparable panel took nearly six years to rule, and the entries it covers stay open while it sits.
Canadian governments and sawmills on November 18 asked for binational panel review, under Article 10.12 of the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement, of both final results of the 2024 administrative reviews of U.S. duties on softwood lumber1,2. The requests surprise no one. Canada’s government reports that the final results of each of the six earlier reviews were also challenged9. What deserves attention is the instrument itself. Chapter 10 review moves a Commerce determination out of U.S. courts and before a binational panel8, and the panel on the first countervailing duty review of the lumber order took, by this journal’s count, almost six years from request to decision7. For an importer of Canadian lumber, the requests mean the 2024 rates published on October 19 are the rates for now, and possibly not the rates that will finally settle those entries.
The instrument: a treaty panel in place of the trade court
Section 516A of the Tariff Act of 1930 ordinarily sends challenges to antidumping and countervailing duty determinations to the U.S. Court of International Trade. Subsection (g) carves out an exception for Canada and Mexico. Once panel review is requested under NAFTA Article 1904 or USMCA Article 10.12, the determination is no longer reviewable in any U.S. court, except in narrow cases the statute lists8. An interested party that took part in the Commerce proceeding has 30 days from publication of the determination to file its request with the U.S. Secretary of the USMCA Secretariat8. Commerce published the 2024 results on October 19, 2026, and the requests came on November 181,2,4.
The panel does not rewrite the duty. Under the procedural rules quoted in both notices, review is limited to the allegations of error of fact or law, including challenges to Commerce’s jurisdiction, set out in the complaints, and to the defenses raised against them1,2. A panel that disagrees with Commerce sends the matter back on remand, and Commerce recalculates.
The statute’s liquidation rules settle who carries the risk in the meantime. As a general rule, entries covered by a challenged determination are liquidated in accordance with it if they entered before notice of a panel decision “not in harmony with that determination” is published8. A participant in the panel review may, however, ask Commerce to order “the continued suspension of liquidation” of entries involved in the review pending its final disposition8. When the requester is a foreign producer, exporter or U.S. importer, the suspension reaches only that party’s own entries8. Neither November notice says whether anyone has made such a request for 2024 entries1,2.
The mechanism: who filed, what they named, and the Resolute correction
There are two cases. The countervailing duty challenge, assigned USA-CDA-2026-10.12-01, was filed by the Government of Canada; the governments of Alberta, British Columbia, New Brunswick, Ontario and Québec; the Alberta and British Columbia lumber trade councils; and Canfor, Interfor, EACOM, Chaleur, J.D. Irving, Tolko, Gilbert Smith and West Fraser1. A second request in the same case came from Resolute FP Canada, the Conseil de l’industrie forestière du Québec, the Ontario Forest Industries Association and their members, together with Plaster Rock Lumber and CHAP Alliance1. The antidumping case, USA-CDA-2026-10.12-02, drew requests from the same two groups, with two differences in the government-led filing: New Brunswick is not listed, and Fontaine Inc. is2.
The deadlines are fixed. Complaints are due December 18, 2026, and any party that does not file a complaint but intends to participate must file a notice of appearance by January 4, 20271,2.
The rates under challenge are those of October 19. In the antidumping review, Commerce set margins of 17.00 percent for Canfor, 13.13 percent for Resolute and 4.71 percent for West Fraser, and 10.64 percent for 220 non-selected producers and exporters, after rescinding the review for 105 companies4. A company never covered by any segment of the case still deposits the 6.04 percent all-others rate from the original investigation4.
The countervailing duty rates moved on November 18, the same day the requests were filed. Resolute alleged on October 20 that Commerce had made a ministerial error, and no other party objected3. Commerce agreed that it had “made an inadvertent error by using an incorrect figure in the final calculations,” and amended Resolute’s subsidy rate from 12.42 to 12.35 percent and the rate for the 215 non-selected companies from 14.11 to 14.08 percent3. West Fraser’s 15.31 percent was unaffected3. The amended deposit rates apply to lumber entered on or after October 19, and Commerce will send assessment instructions to U.S. Customs and Border Protection no earlier than 41 days after the November 19 publication3. By this journal’s count, the combined deposit for non-selected exporters is now 24.72 percent rather than the 24.75 percent reported in October3,4. The countervailing duty request names the October 19 results, not the amended ones1.
The effect: deposits paid now, accounts settled later
For buyers, nothing at the border changes because of a panel request. Deposits continue at the rates above. The question is when the 2024 accounts close. Canada’s government tells exporters that after the first six reviews were challenged and interested parties asked for suspension of liquidation, “the United States would not be expected to issue any refunds until the legal challenges” to those results concluded9. It also warns companies weighing early liquidation that they “could be foregoing a potentially larger refund if Canada is successful in its litigation or as a result of a negotiated agreement”9.
Each side reads the same duties differently. Ottawa’s position is that “In the past, U.S. claims have been found to be without basis. Canada believes this to once again be the case”9. The U.S. Lumber Coalition, the petitioning industry, said in August 2025 that the share of what it calls unfairly traded Canadian lumber had fallen to 21 percent of the U.S. market, and its executive director, Zoltan van Heyningen, pledged to “continue to fight for strong and effective trade law enforcement until Canada stops engaging in unfair trade practices”12. The coalition’s website carries a policy section titled “Eliminating USMCA Chapter 10”12.
Home builders sit between the two. Writing after the 2024 results were announced, the National Association of Home Builders put total duties on Canadian lumber at 34.75 percent once the 10 percent Section 232 tariff is added, and said NAHB “has long opposed lumber tariffs because they undermine housing affordability”11. It urged the administration to “promptly negotiate a new softwood lumber agreement with Canada that eliminates tariffs”11. That 10 percent tariff came out of a separate national security investigation11, and neither panel request names it1,2.
The longer view: what the first USMCA lumber panel shows about time
The best guide to the new cases is the first one. Commerce published the final results of the first countervailing duty review, covering April 2017 through 2018, on December 1, 20207. Canada and Canadian producers requested panel review on December 10, 2020, and the U.S. industry coalition filed a complaint of its own in January 2021, attacking Commerce’s treatment of log export restraints and the British Columbia stumpage benchmark from the other direction7. Appointment of the panel was completed only in early December 2023. The panel heard four days of argument in Washington in September 2024 and issued its decision on October 8, 20267.
That decision affirmed Commerce in part and remanded a long list of findings: benchmarks for Ontario, Alberta and New Brunswick stumpage, the Québec timber auctions, several energy and grant programs, and a recalculation of Canfor’s rate, with a remand determination due within 90 days7. Entries from 2017 and 2018 are therefore still not finally priced. Not every challenge runs to the end. British Columbia records that Canada withdrew its claims against the first and second antidumping reviews in September 2025, and the panels dismissed them10.
The older NAFTA track has just closed. The panel on the 2017 countervailing duty investigation, USA-CDA-2017-1904-02, was completed and its panelists discharged effective November 19, 20266. Commerce had already implemented that panel’s decision on November 3, cutting the all-others subsidy rate from 14.19 to 12.80 percent applicable October 295. Yet the amended 2024 review results, signed November 12, still tell CBP that the all-others subsidy rate “will be 14.19 percent, the all-others subsidy rate established in the investigation”3. Which figure governs a Canadian exporter that has never been reviewed is a question the two notices leave for Commerce to answer.
The Journal’s November essay on the NAFTA panels traced how the 2017 investigations took nine years to clear binational review. The 2024 review now enters the same system, with complaints due December 18.