Skip to the text

National Statecraft Journal

Volume I, No. XLV

Three new USMCA labor cases in November, and a memorandum that lets Mexico call its remedies preventive

Between November 2 and November 19, USTR suspended liquidation on goods from Polygroup, Industrias FG and Madobox. The Industrias Tecnos memorandum shows what happens after a panel request instead: a remediation plan that the two governments describe differently.

The memorandum the United States and Mexico announced on November 2 for Industrias Tecnos, an ammunition plant in Cuernavaca, “details a plan to remedy violations of Mexican law at the facility,” in the words of the Office of the United States Trade Representative6. Mexico’s Secretariat of Labor and Social Welfare tells the story another way. According to IDC Online, which reported the secretariat’s communiqué, the secretariat said its investigation found no indication of violations of freedom of association or collective bargaining at the plant, and presented the agreed steps as preventive measures8. Both accounts describe the same document. Between November 2 and November 19, USTR opened three new matters under the Rapid Response Labor Mechanism of the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement, the latest on November 19 against Polygroup Industrias México, a Chihuahua maker of Christmas goods and swimming pools1,4,5. Read together, the new requests and the Tecnos memorandum show how the mechanism is used: it opens quickly and in many places, and it closes through negotiated texts that each government can describe in its own terms.

The instrument: a request, a customs hold and a panel held in reserve

The mechanism lives in Annex 31-A of the agreement and applies between the United States and Mexico12. When the United States has a good-faith basis to believe that workers at a covered facility are being denied the rights of free association and collective bargaining, it must first ask Mexico to review the matter12. Mexico then has 10 days to say whether it will conduct a review and, if it does, 45 days from the request to report and attempt remediation12. Article 31-A.4.3 lets the complaining party “delay final settlement of customs accounts” for the facility’s goods as soon as the request is delivered12.

Congress turned that clause into a specific power. Section 752(a) of the USMCA Implementation Act lets the Trade Representative direct the Treasury to suspend liquidation of unliquidated entries from the facility13. Section 752(b) lists the only three ways the hold ends: a panel finds no denial of rights, an agreed course of remediation is completed on time, or the denial is “otherwise remedied”13. Tariffs come later, if at all. Under section 753, only after a panel finds a denial of rights may USTR, in consultation with Congress, have goods denied entry or released only on payment of duties and penalties, and apply duties or penalties to the suspended entries13. The agreement itself frames the middle stage as diplomacy. If Mexico finds a denial, the two governments are to consult and agree on remediation “without interrupting trade”12. If Mexico finds none, the United States may accept that result or go to a panel12.

The reach is wide by design. A covered facility is any plant in a priority sector that makes goods or supplies services traded with, or competing in, the other country, and the priority sectors are manufactured goods, services and mining12. A footnote lists examples of manufactured goods running from autos and aerospace to industrial baked goods, pottery and plastic12.

The mechanism: three plants, three requests

Madobox, November 2. The plant in Uruapan, Michoacán, makes boxes for commercial use5. A union affiliated with the Confederación Central Nacional (COCENA) filed the petition on September 30, alleging that the company arranged a collective bargaining agreement negotiated without workers, coerced and misinformed workers about it, and dismissed workers in retaliation for union activity5.

Industrias FG, November 13. The Morelos plant makes polyurethane hydraulic seals used in machinery that includes pistons4. The Sindicato Nacional de Trabajadoras y Trabajadores de Industrias y Servicios “Ricardo Flores Magón” petitioned on October 134. It alleged that the company coerced workers to back a union of the company’s choice, refused to bargain with the authorized union and dismissed workers for union activity, along with interrogations, harassment and threats4.

Polygroup, November 19. The petition came on October 20 from a chemical and pharmaceutical industry union and 11 Polygroup workers, alleging interference with union activity and threats to fire workers1. The formal request asks Mexico to review “all actions taken by the Company to interfere with workers’ right to vote to unionize and to select a union,” including anti-union messages and threats of dismissal2. USTR’s letter to the Treasury directs that liquidation be suspended for “all unliquidated entries of goods produced at the Facility”3.

Each request followed the same sequence. The Interagency Labor Committee, which the Trade Representative and the Secretary of Labor co-chair, reviewed the petition within 30 days, found “sufficient, credible evidence” of a denial of rights, and USTR then filed the request and directed the Treasury to suspend liquidation1,4,5. In none of the three releases does USTR say whether Mexico has agreed to review1,4,5. The products matter less than the sector test. Cartons, seals and holiday plastics all count as manufactured goods under the annex, which names plastic expressly12. The Journal’s October essay on the mechanism followed earlier cases at auto suppliers, a mine and a food plant.

The effect: what an importer of record carries while the account stays open

For a U.S. buyer of Polygroup pools or Madobox cartons, nothing changes at the border on the day of the request. No added duty applies, and the goods enter as before1,5. What changes is finality. Each entry stays open, and its final duty is not settled, until USTR tells the Treasury that one of the section 752(b) conditions has been met13. If a panel later finds a denial of rights, duties or penalties can reach back to those open entries13. An importer buying from a facility under review carries that contingency for as long as the case runs.

How long that is varies. On October 2, the two governments agreed a course of remediation at Corporación de Occidente, a tire maker in El Salto, Jalisco, including reinstatement with backpay or full severance for twelve dismissed workers11. USTR called it the fourteenth formal course of remediation under the mechanism11. The petition there was filed on October 28, 2025, so by this journal’s count the remediation came about eleven months later11.

Business groups say that wait is the problem. A U.S. Chamber of Commerce analysis published in March argued that suspension of liquidation “can impact the admissibility and duty calculations of goods,” that nothing requires the company to be told of the allegations before it is imposed, and that they are rarely involved in planning the remediation14. It cited the Akwel plant in Ciudad Juárez, where a petition filed on October 24, 2024 led to a course of remediation only on February 3, 2026, and recalled the Chamber’s October 2025 request for 24 hours’ notice of a petition and a chance to respond14.

Labor scholars weigh the same record differently. Writing for Brookings in March, Mark Anner of Rutgers University concluded that the mechanism compares favorably with the labor chapters of NAFTA and the Dominican Republic-Central America Free Trade Agreement, and counted 10 cases in which workers formed independent unions and then bargained for substantially better wages15. He also argued that reforms are needed to extend that impact to a larger share of Mexican workers15.

The longer view: how Industrias Tecnos moved from a panel request to a memorandum

The Tecnos case shows the other route through the annex. The United States asked Mexico to review the plant on June 24, 2024, the 24th invocation of the mechanism, and suspended liquidation on its goods9. The petitioning union, Sindicato Metálico, alleged that the company and the incumbent union discouraged workers from joining it and dismissed workers for union activity9. Mexico’s 45-day review found no denial of rights10. On December 18, 2024, the United States requested a panel, its sixth under the agreement, saying it considered the denial “to be ongoing”10.

Nearly two years later the result is a memorandum, not a panel report. The text, dated October 1, 2026, records that payments owed to the dismissed workers were verified on June 26, 20267. It requires a neutrality statement, training for supervisors and “trusted” staff, an anonymous complaint channel and sanctions under Mexican law where violations are found, with actions due by October 15, 20267. Mexico’s labor secretariat also agreed to a limited-scope investigation of the plant’s hiring and dismissal rates and its use of private termination agreements7. According to IDC Online, the secretariat described the memorandum as a step toward closing the case8.

The memorandum lets both governments keep their positions. Washington records remedies for violations of Mexican law, and Mexico City records preventive commitments after an investigation that found none6,8. Annex 31-A allows this. It provides for a panel when the parties disagree, but nothing in it requires one12. What it settles is not yet stated. The memorandum commits the two governments to try to determine, within 30 days after it expires, whether implementation has been adequate, and to name any pending issue in that period7. Neither the November 2 release nor the memorandum says whether USTR has told the Treasury that a section 752(b) condition has been met for the Tecnos entries held since June 20246,7,9,13. Which of the three conditions such a notice would cite, for a case in which Mexico found no denial of rights and no panel has ruled, is a question neither government has yet answered in public.