Volume I, No. XXXVII
Cleared in 2024, found dumping in 2026: the second tin mill case reaches Taiwan and Türkiye
The same two mills that drew zero margins in the 2023 tin mill case now face preliminary rates of 18.07 and 3.89 percent. The swing comes from a new petition, a new period of investigation and the 2 percent de minimis line, and the Trade Commission that ended the last case holds its hearing December 4.
The Commerce Department has found preliminary dumping by the same two foreign mills it cleared less than three years ago. Notices published November 10 set a margin of 18.07 percent for Ton Yi Industrial Corporation of Taiwan and 3.89 percent for the Tosyali group of Türkiye, and Commerce has told Customs to start collecting cash deposits1,2. In January 2024 each company’s margin was 0.00 percent, and the cases against Taiwan and Turkey ended there8,9. Nothing in the trade remedy statute prevents a domestic industry from trying again, and the 2026 petition did. Its first round of results shows how much an antidumping finding depends on which twelve months Commerce examines, and how little separates a dismissal from an order when the threshold is two percent.
The instrument: a new period, the same statute
Antidumping duties rest on section 731 of the Tariff Act of 1930 and run on two tracks. Commerce decides whether goods are sold in the United States at less than fair value; the U.S. International Trade Commission decides whether those imports injure or threaten a domestic industry11,12. At the preliminary stage, Commerce must disregard any weighted-average margin that is de minimis, which for an investigation means less than 2 percent ad valorem11. The same rule governs the final determination12.
That threshold explains the 2024 outcome. Commerce measured Ton Yi’s and Tosyali’s sales over calendar 2022 and found no dumping margin at all for either8,9. The current investigations cover April 1, 2025 through March 31, 20261,2. The respondents are the same companies; the sales, costs and prices are different, and on those numbers both margins now clear the 2 percent line. Tosyali’s clears it by less than two points2.
Two other provisions shape what happens next. Section 733(d) limits provisional measures to four months, extendable to six at the request of exporters accounting for a significant share of exports11. Section 735(a)(2) lets Commerce postpone its final determination to 135 days after the preliminary if such exporters ask12. Ton Yi made both requests on September 8, and Commerce granted them1. Nobody did so in the Türkiye case, which keeps the ordinary limit of 75 days after the preliminary was signed on November 52. By this journal’s count, that places the Türkiye final by January 19, 2027 and the Taiwan final by March 25, 2027.
Section 733(e) supplies the last tool. Where Commerce finds a reasonable basis to suspect a history of dumping, or importer knowledge of it, together with massive imports over a relatively short period, it can reach back before the preliminary determination11. Commerce made that finding for one Turkish exporter, Tatrix Internation2. The Taiwan notice contains no critical-circumstances finding1.
The mechanism: what changes at entry?
The scope is identical across the three countries. It covers flat-rolled steel coated or plated with tin, chromium or chromium oxides: tinplate, and the tin-free steel also called electrolytic chromium-coated steel, in any thickness, width, form, temper or coating weight, and whether or not plastic-coated1. One product is carved out: a single-reduced chromium-coated steel tape used to armor fiber optic and telecommunications cables, and only if it meets all seven listed specifications1. Commerce preliminarily modified the scope language from the initiation notice after comments, as recorded in a September 8 scope memorandum1,2. The HTSUS subheadings listed are 7210.11.0000, 7210.12.0000, 7210.50.0020, 7210.50.0090, 7212.10.0000 and 7212.50.0000 for non-alloy steel and 7225.99.0090 and 7226.99.0180 for alloy steel, with the written description controlling1.
For Taiwan, Ton Yi was the only respondent, so its 18.07 percent rate is also the all-others rate1. For Türkiye, Commerce treated Tosyali Toyo Celik and Toscelik Profil ve Sac Endustrisi as a single entity at 3.89 percent, which also becomes the all-others rate. Tatrix received 42.06 percent based on facts available with adverse inferences2. Liquidation is suspended, and cash deposits are required, for entries on or after November 101,2. For Tatrix, because of the critical circumstances finding, suspension reaches unliquidated entries made on or after the date 90 days before publication2.
Chinese tinplate is further along. In September Commerce set a preliminary countervailing duty rate of 66.61 percent for two Shougang entities and all others, based on adverse facts available, with critical circumstances5. The antidumping preliminary that followed assigned the China-wide entity 136.52 percent, also on adverse facts, with a cash deposit of 130.17 percent after a subsidy offset; no Chinese respondent qualified for a separate rate4. Commerce aligned the China countervailing duty final with the China antidumping final5, which was to come no later than 75 days after the September 16 signature4. By this journal’s count that date is November 30, 2026.
The calculated rates sit far below what was alleged. Commerce’s initiation notice recorded petition margins of 60.68 to 137.24 percent for Taiwan and 41.11 to 198.04 percent for Türkiye3.
The effect: who carries the deposits?
The petitioners this time are United States Steel Corporation and the United Steelworkers, and they told Commerce that the union represents workers accounting for all U.S. production of tin mill products, so the petition carried 100 percent industry support3. The ITC found a reasonable indication of injury from all three countries in May6.
The buyers are can makers. Tinplate goes mainly into welded cans for food, aerosol, paint and general-line uses, and chromium-coated steel into two-piece drawn cans, can ends and closures for glass containers, according to Clark Hill’s summary of the petition14. Faegre Drinker, writing on the day of filing, warned purchasers to expect higher prices or less supply, and noted that importers would be liable for any duties imposed13.
The Can Manufacturers Institute has made its position clear in both rounds. In February 2024 it said steel can makers “commend” the ITC’s negative vote and called the earlier petition “completely unfounded”16. In March 2026, before the new case reached a preliminary stage, its president, Scott Breen, said U.S. companies import nearly 80 percent of their tinplate, and that “We need to make sure that we have the tinplate steel we need at a competitive price”15. Packaging Dive reported then that the group was pressing to bring down Section 232 tariffs on tinplate steel and aluminum, which the administration had not rolled back15. Any antidumping deposits now arrive on top of that.
Cleveland-Cliffs, the 2024 petitioner, responded to its loss in one line: “While we are disappointed by today’s ITC determination, we must respect the ruling”16. U.S. Steel’s view in the current case appears in the record as its petition and alleged margins3.
The longer view: the second attempt and the vote that matters
The 2023 case was broader and ended in two stages. Cleveland-Cliffs and the Steelworkers petitioned against eight countries10,16. Commerce found no dumping by the Netherlands, Taiwan, Turkey and the United Kingdom, and the ITC terminated those four investigations in January 202410. On the remaining four, the Commission found in February 2024 that the domestic industry was neither materially injured nor threatened by imports from Canada, China and Germany, and that South Korean imports were negligible10. The vote was unanimous16. No duties resulted.
The 2026 case reverses the order of risk. Commerce has now cleared nothing; every country named has an affirmative preliminary1,2,4. But the agency that ended the last case was the Commission, and its final phase is under way: the prehearing staff report goes on the nonpublic record November 18, prehearing briefs are due November 27, the hearing opens at 9:30 a.m. on December 4 and posthearing briefs are due December 117. If Commerce’s finals are affirmative, the Commission must vote by the later of 120 days after the preliminary or 45 days after the final12.
The 2024 Commission weighed an industry that relied on imports and found no injury. The 2026 Commission will weigh a petition backed by a different steelmaker, with different country coverage and a different period of data, against purchasers who told the 2024 Commission they depend on imported tinplate and who said again this year that they import most of it15,16. Whether the Commission reads the record the same way is the open question for the December 4 hearing.